Employee or Contractor? Start There.
Most payroll problems we untangle don’t start with a math error. They start with one question that never got asked: is this person an employee or a contractor?
The answer decides what you withhold, what you owe, and what you file. Get it right and payroll is routine. Get it wrong and you may be looking at back taxes and penalties for work that was paid months ago.
How to tell the difference
It isn’t a matter of preference, and it isn’t settled by what you call someone or what the agreement says. It comes down to how the work actually happens.
Who controls the work. If you set the hours, decide how the job gets done, and train them on your way of doing it, that points toward an employee.
Who carries the cost. If you provide the tools, the equipment, and the workspace, that points toward an employee. A contractor generally brings their own and covers their own expenses.
How the relationship works. A contractor usually has other clients, sends invoices, and is hired for a specific job. Someone who works for you steadily, with no end date, as a regular part of the business is more likely an employee.
No single factor decides it. When the answer isn’t obvious, it’s worth asking before the first payment rather than after the first year.
What changes once you have an employee
With a contractor, you pay the invoice and the contractor handles their own taxes. With an employee, that responsibility shifts to you.
Each paycheck now has income tax, Social Security, and Medicare taken out of it. That part comes from the employee’s pay.
The business also pays taxes of its own. You match the Social Security and Medicare withheld from each employee, dollar for dollar, and pay federal and state unemployment tax on top of that. These are real costs to the business, and they’re easy to overlook when you’re budgeting for a new hire.
All of it has to be sent in on a set schedule and reported to the IRS and the state every quarter. At the end of the year, each employee gets a W-2.
None of it is difficult once it’s set up. The hard part is that it never stops — every pay period, every quarter, every January — and the penalties for a missed deadline add up quickly.
Why many owners hand it off
Payroll is the kind of work that has to be done right every time, on time, without exception. It doesn’t get easier because the business is busy, and it’s usually the first thing to slip when it is.
That’s why we run payroll for many of our clients. We set it up correctly from the start, process each payroll, handle the deposits, and file the quarterly and year-end reports. If a notice shows up from the IRS or the state, it comes to someone who already knows your account.
The advantage of having it in one place
When the same firm handles your payroll, your books, and your tax return, the pieces line up. We can see what payroll is actually costing the business, catch a problem before it reaches your return, and make sure the numbers on your W-2s match everything else.
For S corporation owners, it also means the salary you pay yourself is reviewed alongside the rest of your tax picture — not set once and forgotten.
If you’re not sure where you stand
Maybe you’ve been paying someone as a contractor and you’re starting to wonder. Maybe you’re about to hire your first employee. Or maybe you’re running payroll yourself and would rather not.
Any of those is a good reason to talk. Reach out through our contact page — we’d be glad to sit down with you, look at how your workers are set up, and talk through taking payroll off your plate.